Contrast and Underspecification. The Semantics of aber and doch
نویسندگان
چکیده
I present an unitary analysis of the German adversative connectors aber and doch, based on Sæbø (2003), where the semantics of these connectors is defined in terms of a presupposition involving negation and topic alternatives. I argue that the meaning of aber and doch is underspecified between various types of contrast and that the type of contrast they indicate in particular context is determined by the configuration of topic alternatives at hand, which in turn is correlated with the particular syntactic and prosodic properties of the connectors in the concrete discourse as well as with the type of discourse (coordination, dialogue) in which the connectors are used. Finally, I sketch an underspecified semantic representation of the meaning of aber and doch and hint at a disambiguation algorithm that allows the bottom up construction of discourses with these connectors starting from their underspecified representation and employing information about their syntactic and prosodic properties as well as about the information structure and the discourse structure of the particular context in which they occur.
منابع مشابه
Contrast and underspecification
It has been argued that there is a close relationship between the notions of contrast in discourse structure and in information structure, as well as between corrections and denial and information structural contrast (cf. e.g. Umbach 2004). Recent analyses of the semantics of markers of such contrastive relations, such as but and aber , suggest that the discourse objects that are being contrast...
متن کاملMaximale Flüsse - Die ganze Stadt will zum Stadion
" Was ist denn das für ein Mist, so kommen wir ja nie zum Fußballstadion! " Jogi saß im Auto neben seiner Mutter und wurde langsam unruhig. " Ich kann doch auch nichts dafür, dass alle diese Straße zum Stadion benutzen. Jetzt ist eben Stau " , meinte sie nur. – " Dann dreh' doch einfach um und wir nehmen da hinten die Fordstraße, die Route benutzt keiner. " Jogis Mutter glaubte zwar nicht so re...
متن کاملConjunct adverb doch and the notion of contrast
The paper contributes to the ongoing discussion on the relation between information structure and discourse structure. It presents an account of the German conjunct adverb doch (dochCA) that is based on the observation that the interaction between the two structures determines the semantic and pragmatic properties of this conjunct adverb. The account of dochCA presented thus defends a monosemic...
متن کاملSchrift - Wissen - Wissensmanagement
„Denn dieses Schlimme hat doch die Schrift, Phaidros, und ist darin ganz eigentlich der Malerei ähnlich: denn auch diese stellt ihre Ausgeburten hin als lebend, wenn man sie aber etwas fragt, so schweigen sie gar ehrwürdig still. Eben so auch die Schriften. Du könntest glauben sie sprächen als verständen sie etwas, fragst du sie aber lernbegierig über das Gesagte, so enthalten sie doch nur ein ...
متن کاملThe Semantics of the Word Istikbar (Arrogance) in the Holy Quran based on Syntagmatic Relations(A Case Study of Semantic Proximity and Semantic Contrast)
The word istikbar (arrogance) is one of the key words in the monotheistic system of the Quran, which has found a special status as a special feature of the opponents and adversaries of the call to the truth. Given the prominent role of this issue in the human life system and its provision of corruption and moral deviations, it is necessary to represent the nature of the elements that make up th...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2008